This sword is amaizing, a bit heavy, but amazing. No defect on the guard, on the pommel, nothing, even the scabbard fit perfectly. What do you want more ?
February 11, 2018
For the price you will have a hard time finding a better sword! I love the simple look and it just feels right in the hand. My only complaint is that the pommel was peened crooked, however it doesn't affect function.
February 11, 2017
MR shipped very promptly. I chose the sword sharpened. Although that gave it a secondary bevel, it looks nice and feels sharp. Overall the sword is just beautiful. A perfect satin finish makes the blade irresistible to look at. The design is simple, elemental, and classical. The weight and balance feel almost spot on to me, though if I had to complain, I would say it is minutely blade heavy. The ricasso was left unsharpened, however, which allows for an alternative grip further up the sword. The sword came heavily oiled from top to bottom. A tad unappealing at first, but I ultimately appreciate the protection. I have done very little cutting so far, but it seemed to handle it easily. Moreover, the guard feels very solidly attached. The gap between the cross guard and the blade is refreshingly slim, and filled with what appears to be epoxy. The pommel is solid and nicely peened to the tang. I've seen smoother peens I guess, but I am very pleased with this one. When I look down the blade at a shallow angle I can see the gently waving imperfections that confess the sword's hand forged origins. I just love that look. With each gentle mark the blade subtly and beautifully narrates the story of each hammer blow in it's creation. No stock removal blade gives me the same feeling. The scabbard ends up being my only major complaint. It's not terrible. It looks nice, it matches, and it fits more snugly than I expected. Though I can already feel it getting looser. Yes it is a tad flimsy feeling. But, the real problem I have with it is the amount of residue it leaves on the blade. Every time I draw the sword, it comes out spattered and streaked by some white-ish mystery material. Oh how I wish it came out clean. Overall I debated with myself at length about whether or not to give this weapon 5 stars. Ultimately, despite the fact that I feel like I easily got more than my money's worth, I feel like I must reserve a perfect score for a near-perfect sword. If they could make the quality of the scabbard match that of the sword, they would have a truly mythic package for this price.
December 13, 2016
A beautiful, solid piece of equipment, and well worth the price.
November 27, 2016
I received this sword sooner than expected and securely packaged. It was expertly sharpened and I tested it by opening a letter with it, as well as my finger because I forgot that I was dealing with a REAL sharpened blade, not one of my step-fathers kitchen knives (he refuses to use anything but scalloped edge knives because "sharp knives scare me to death!"). The sheath holds the sword quite securely by the top 2,3 inches of the blade and keeps the sharp edges from cutting the sides of the scabbard. As is quite obvious, my knowledge of swords is quite rudimentary. It feels comfortable and well balanced when I'm swinging it around (outside with plenty of free space). I am not a small statured man, so I don't find it heavy at all. Over all, I think it is a good sword for a greenie like me to start out on. The only reason I don't give it a 5 star is because it doesn't sharpen itself!
September 23, 2016
Beautifully balanced, with the perfect amount of flex so not too whippy! Sword handles amazingly and the fittings on mine are perfectly aligned, with no rattles to speak of. First head about this sword through the SBG review and have had my eye on it for a while. One thing I noticed though, is that the fuller on mine is almost twice as wide as any other Windlass European swords I have seen, which in my opinion makes the blade super attractive, and much more aesthetically pleasing for my personal taste. My one gripe is that the fuller ground on one side of the blade veers off on a haphazard angle for about 3 inches near the tip-end which really detracts from what would otherwise be a great finish for the price. Because of this flaw, I should only give four stars in review of the particular blade I received. It still performs flawlessly though, and I am sure MRL would swap for a new sword if it's owner was overly affected by any major errors in the product's finish - therefore I will award it the 5-star rating it deserves.
August 17, 2016
It is exactly what it is advertised to be. An excellent basic functional sword that cannot be beat at its original price point and a steal in closeout. Well crafted simplicity at its best. The second I have owned and not much changed from the first I bought over 15 years ago. Why they would discontinue such a time-tested sword is beyond me...but all things I suppose must come to an end. Unfortunately, I received this one damaged due to some very negligent shipping but I can't express enough how helpful the customer service is at Museum Replicas. A shipping label was immediately sent to me and upon their receiving the original, even though I was informed it could be a 6 week wait due to the closeout, a replacement was found and shipped out (express) on the same day. A solid and very trustworthy company that I look forward to dealing with again in the future.
July 18, 2016
Looks, I was fairly pleased, as with the weight. However the balance is really tip heavy. When I examined the blade closely I noticed that the blade's taper is reversed from what it should be. The tip is thicker than the base. Despite this the weight still makes it fairly easy to move around but it does tire you quickly.
July 09, 2016
We buy these swords as a presentation to the incoming President of the Sheriff's Assn. High quality and historical accuracy makes these swords perfect for our use.
December 10, 2015
I put my review on this sword under the classic sword,sorry if you would like to see it ck the review by ray Blundell on the classic sword.
December 10, 2015
5 Stars because it seems to live up to the very favorable reviews I've read elsewhere... Bare Bones.. Functional as is... Future project sword for me...
November 25, 2015
This is a very nice sword. Handles well, great balance. Simple but well built.
November 14, 2015
Very simple and very functional. Solid construction from what I can tell. Not the best looking sword in my collection but definitely is functional. Recommended if you want a sword to use not a wall hanger.
December 02, 2014
Excellent sword. Definitely one of the best Museum Replicas offers. I wrote a full review on the sword on the Sword-Buyers-Guide if you would like to read more about this sword.
August 30, 2014
I read reviews on it at swordbuyersguide.com before buying it, and I was relieved to find that it was everything it was said to be and more! The sword is a simple design, but it's put together well (nothing is loose or rattling), and cuts well.
November 25, 2013