If it were not for the lack of quality in the buttons, I'd give the coat a 5 star rating. The fabric quality is quite good as is the construction. The downside, and its a biggie, is the cheap plastic used for the covered buttons. One shank broke on the first wearing when I turned at an awkward angle. Luckily, I was able to salvage the top half of the button to make a replacement. A second button, on the sleeve had its top pop off on the second wearing. No idea where it went. Museum Replicas does not have replacement buttons so I'll be spending quality time at various fabric stores trying to match the fabric to make a replacement button. Very, very annoying.