To start with these are not leather. That is completely fine with me. I purchased these as an alternative to dropping $700 on a pair of real leather boots sight unseen. They are well made. The sizing is a little odd. I ordered a medium which is size 10-11. I wear a 10 and they were pretty loose. I was worried and inquired about returning them. Upon further inspection I realized they had no insole in them at all. I took a pair of insoles out of some of my work boots which fit very well, and dropped it in. While feeling around to see the fitment on the inside the insole fits perfect. The variance is in the part of the boot that goes over the top of the foot is a little big. Once the insoles were in I put them on, and they fit perfect. That’s what it was missing is the insole. If you are thinking about buying these boots, do it. They are worth the money. Fit and finish is spot on. For being pleather they are great and I’m sure will hold up quite well. The buttons I have a feeling might possibly rip out but that’s ok cause I keep a couple of spare conchos in my sewing kit for just such a thing. Great boot for the price, I highly recommend.