Probably deserves a solid 3.5, but 4 works. Knife itself is fairly nice. Generally good Windlass quality. I like it a good bit. But the scabbard is definitely iffy, considering how loosely it fits the knife. But thats ok, its not exactly meant for use anyways.
solid manufactured weapon, this one is one of my favorites, fits the hand well, though I can
see that the decoration could be a problem on the handle. I have owned this one for about 3 years and have had no problems with it.
Sturdy.Solid. Nasty. Lends itself to techniques that that straight blades are less effective at. I like it!
This a great knife. It holds a nice edge and is great looking. I glued a little wool felt in the sheath to make it fit a little tighter is all.
One of The ornamentation on the handle fell off after I dropped it on my driveway on accident, just need to glue it back on.
I got mine sharpened and good god was it sharp, nearly cut my finger off with a stupid move on my part... Just need to glue it back on >__>
The knife itself is just fine, but the scabbard does not hold the knife properly. It is only loosely held.