Although I sent this back, I give it 4 stars b/c it is basically as the picture shows - a decent shirt. Design-wise, I didn't care for the fabric (pretty much sheer) or the leather loops designed to hold the buttons at the back of the neck (it looks like it just wants to break). I purchased this shirt to go with the Eddard Stark gambeson (which I love), but the material around the shirt's neck bunched up like a frill. It would take quite of bit of pulling and tucking to make that lie flat.